Haley Opposes SC Bailout For PGA Tourney


From Business Week/Associated Press

SC approves keeping PGA tournament loan in budget


South Carolina legislators voted Wednesday to keep a $10 million loan to the state’s only PGA tournament in the state budget.

The House voted 69-43 to loan the money if the Heritage golf tournament on Hilton Head Island can’t find a sponsor to replace Verizon, which says this is its final year as sponsor. If needed, the loan would come from the state’s insurance reserve fund.

Opponents said it didn’t make sense in a year of deep cuts to services, including layoffs of teachers, state law enforcement, public defenders and Juvenile Justice workers, as well as possible cuts to services for the disabled.

Rep. Nikki Haley led an effort to remove the loan from the state’s $5 billion spending plan — which is down from $7 billion two years ago.

“In a budget year like this, they raided the insurance trust fund — a fund that’s meant to protect consumers after hurricanes and natural disasters — to lend money to a golf tournament. That is so far removed from what our taxpayers want,” said the Lexington Republican.

She criticized federal bailouts of banks and car companies, adding, “Now, we’re going to bail out golf courses. When’s it going to stop?” She asked whether South Carolina would next lend money to steeplechase races.

Supporters of the loan accused the gubernatorial candidate of playing political games.

“Most people are pragmatic. Most are smart enough to see through this,” said Rep. Leon Stavrinakis, D-Charleston. “It supports us. It’s good for the people we represent.”

Democrats and Republicans argued the tournament — held in April following the Masters in Augusta, Ga. — supports hundreds of jobs and pumps tens of millions of dollars into the state through spectators’ spending. According to a Clemson study, more than 70 percent of spectators live outside Beaufort County.

“This is a proven moneymaker for the state of South Carolina,” said Rep. Richard Chalk, R-Hilton Head Island.

Rep. Bill Herbkersman, R-Bluffton, said the vote was about showing South Carolina’s commitment.

While acknowledging golf can be an elitist sport, Rep. Jim Merrill said the tournament boosts South Carolina’s image worldwide in a state that relies on tourism, which includes golfing at 360 courses statewide. The Daniel Island Republican said the state must show its support or risk seeing the tournament go elsewhere.

He noted South Carolina has already lost a NASCAR event. Darlington Raceway had been an end-of-the-summer NASCAR tradition from 1950 through 2003 when it hosted the Southern 500 on Labor Day weekend as the second of its two NASCAR weekends. The track’s second NASCAR weekend disappeared in 2005, when the Southern 500 moved to the California Speedway.

“The minute we don’t show support for these tournaments, Georgia will, North Carolina will, Virginia will. We’ve got to be a player in these things,” Merrill said.

The nonprofit Heritage Classic Foundation — the tournament’s general sponsor — reported giving more than $1.3 million to charities in 2009, bringing the total to $19.8 million since 2007.

Heritage tournament director Steve Wilmot did not immediately return a message Wednesday from The Associated Press.

[emphasis added]

Of course, the three quoted Representatives are from the Low Country near Hilton Head.

Remember when Governor Mark Sanford didn’t want to take federal stimulus funds?  He was vilified because to NOT take those monies would lead to teachers being fired and prisoners let loose on the streets of the Palmetto State.  Now, some of those same voices want to use $10 million to prop up a golf tournament. 

I like golf – much better than it likes me – but isn’t it fair to say that this money would be better spent on keeping teachers in classrooms and criminals in jail?

In these times, times referred to by legislators themselves as “dire,” is loaning taxpayer money to a golf tournament a sign of good fiscal stewardship?


5 thoughts on “Haley Opposes SC Bailout For PGA Tourney

  1. If Nikki Haley is “playing political games” then she’s been playing political games for several years now.

    Frankly, as long as she’s fighting the spendthrifts, I don’t care what her motives are though I am convinced she’s genuinely concerned about these issues and her fight is a good one.

    At what point do these crooks in the statehouse admit what they’re doing? If it’s a “real moneymaker,” why do they need taxpayer money?

    If it’s okay to give the money away to the corporation(s) involved then why isn’t it okay to just give it straight to the residents? That would certainly be “good for the people [they] represent,” right? And it would certainly be more efficient.

    We have incredibly brazen scam artists in the statehouse.


  2. Let me get this straight. We’re giving $10 million to this tournament, partially because “it supports hundreds of jobs…”

    …for one week.

    Also, we didn’t lose Darlington because of lack of support. NASCAR wanted a “higher end” brand of racing, so they took it and moved it to tracks out west where nobody is showing up. If we told NASCAR we’d give them $10 million to bring the race back, they’d do it in a heartbeat. And that brings more out-of-state visitors than the Heritage, by a mile.

    And if it’s such a money-maker, why do they need the $10 million? Why is Verizon pulling out?

    Their financials for 2009 were pretty good:

    “Continued cash flow growth in 4Q 2009: $31.6 billion in cash flow from operations in 2009, up $4.0 billion, or 14.5 percent, from 2008. Net loss of $0.23 per share is improved from $0.43 per share in 4Q 2008.

    In the fourth quarter 2009, Verizon’s total operating revenues grew 9.9 percent to $27.1 billion, compared with the fourth quarter 2008. This includes revenues from Alltel, which Verizon acquired in January 2009. On a pro forma basis (consolidating the operating results of Verizon and the former Alltel as though the acquisition had occurred on Jan. 1, 2008), fourth-quarter 2009 operating revenue growth was 0.2 percent, compared with the fourth quarter 2008.

    For 2009, annual operating revenues totaled $107.8 billion, an increase of 10.7 percent from 2008 on a reported basis and 1.5 percent on a pro forma basis.

    Cash flow from operations totaled $31.6 billion in 2009, up 14.5 percent, or $4.0 billion, from 2008. Free cash flow (non-GAAP; cash flow from operations less capital expenditures) totaled $14.5 billion in 2009, up $4.2 billion from 2008. Verizon’s capital expenditures were $17.0 billion in 2009, compared with $17.2 billion in 2008.”

    Sounds like they’re doing better financially than the state of South Carolina.

    It better be called, “The Heritage Golf Tournament, presented by the Taxpayers of South Carolina.” If they put that in big letters every time the tournament is written about, and had it on every logo-t-shirt, hat, golf towel, newspaper ad, and TV shot, I’d be all for it.

    The part that’s really bad is that it’s coming from our emergency insurance fund. That’s a great idea.

    Do I get tickets?


  3. Pingback: South Carolina and the PGA Scorecard « The Garnet Spy

  4. Why is it that we can give hundreds of millions for incentives for manufacturing jobs but we cant loan 10 million for something in the tourism sector?


    • Ahh.. JB, but there’s the rub. If the State spent $10M to promote golf in SC, that’s different, but the only tourism that would be promoted here is ONE event for ONE WEEK. That isn’t promoting tourism, especially since that event is at an exclusive course on a relatively remote location.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s